I really like "Dirty English" by Juicy Couture, it's quite manly but not overwhelming. I think it suites me well because it compliments my rugged good-looks, but also hints at my more sensitive side.
It's also got that balance of muskiness and leathery undertones (which I really love).
Are you looking for something to buy your dad for father's day? If so, I'd recommend checking out this similar question that Mel posted here: www.blurtit.com/q2390460.html